Oct 09
2008

It's not monkey business

Posted by Pablo Santos in Open Source.NET

PSantos

 Software is all about illusion. Yes, I mean it! Just get rid of the methods, the best practices, the documents, strip everything away and try to focus on the essential.

Don't you remember the feeling? The sensation you get when you finish this piece of code and for a few seconds you feel you're on the top. Mr. Glass makes a much better definition talking about fun, the fun about software development. Yes, forget the business for one second and just remember why you got involved on this first. Most likely at the beginning that good feeling was much easier to achieve, wasn't it? Ok, if you don't get the point you're probably not a programmer, so I bet you've a thousand better things to do than reading this coder's post.

Still here? Then let's talk about a great announcement I read only 4 days ago: Mono 2.0 is out!

(Tune to some monkey music for your reading pleasure! :-P)

Yes, Mono (you're still wondering why I started talking about illusion, right? Be patient), the .NET platform for every non-windows OS out there!

The Mono team has released their better version so far, including a number of huge improvements such us .NET 2.0 compatibility (yes, generics and everything), the initial Moonlight (Silverlight for Linux) and many more.

But the best is yet to come: they already have LINQ and lambda expressions (.NET 3.5) almost there, ParallelFX (the multi-core .NET library) and totally new stuff.

When people talk about Mono, they normally focus on its compatibility with the .NET platform and how good it is for a number of companies tied to the Microsoft stack. But let me look at it from a different perspective.

I started the post talking about illusion, and that's all about Mono. Yes, writing C# code gives you more "good moments" than most of its language counterparts. Strange point of view? Yes, I admit it, but it was so true for me. I grew up as a Pascal programmer who switched to C and later to C++. I've developed Delphi code for a while and turned to Java around 2001. For a long time I was a Windows-only developer but my move to Java came together with the Solaris (7 or 8 if I remember correctly) OS. I enjoyed so much learning about the Solaris internals  (there's a new and improved edition also available, in case you're interested) , that I become a Unix fan. Now, the problem, is I don't feel at home anywhere since I always miss something from Linux or Solaris or the latest Windows box :-(

C++ is still my favorite language but, admittedly, it is more Platonic than it's real. And only after all that I entered C# and .NET. The first thing I ever wrote in C# was the Plastic SCM server loader, which is a piece of code which loads some components from different assemblies, driven by a XML load script, and links these components together at run time pluging the ones implementing the same interfaces in a chain. Basically they're layered components: some implement the core, some security, some transactions, some triggers...

Loading them dynamically at runtime, linking them in a chain to separate different concerns, was extremely easy with C#. It just worked! I mean, now I'm used to it (I'm probably weaker), but I drew the design on a piece of paper, started coding, and it compiled and worked immediately.

Come on! It would have never worked in C++ the first time, not even the second. There's always this pointer you miss, this tricky issue, whatever, it's not that easy. So, yes, let's face it, C# is more productive! And, coming back to my initial thoughts on illusion and good moments: it helps you having more good moments than any other platform I've used.

Then, the problem is that C# (I never really developed in VB.NET and my past experiences with old good (bad) Visual Basic are not worth telling) is only available in Windows, so any serious multi-platform project is simply out of the scope... No C# on my beloved Solaris or on Linux. But, Miguel de Icaza changed everything when he and his band of monkeys started Mono!! Now the best platform was available everywhere! Great!

And here's my whole point: Mono is not always moving Windows code to Linux. Mono is all about a powerful platform for Unix operating systems. Of course, whenever you say something like that, everyone will ask: "What about Java?" In my case the answer is simple, although more emotional than rational: I've worked on both, and I still prefer C# to Java. If I only had to choose one single feature on .NET/Mono which I consider worth the whole decision, I'd take remoting. I used to develop a lot of DCOM (yes, D-COM, not only COM as it was named at the end, DCOM, the one described at the book of the Eddon's which I loved reading and finally understanding almost one decade ago) and remoting is the best thing I've ever found! I love it. I use it on a daily basis, I think it is great and I haven't found a compelling replacement (ok, there can be alternative implementations of the same concept, but remoting is, simply, great!).

Unfortunately Mono is not (yet) perfect, and there're still a lot of things to improve, including portability, or maybe I should say packaging. They've versions for a number of OSs, but the latest versions are not always available from them, which makes Mono weaker than its Java competitor for a huge number of developers.

And there's a lot to evolve too, but IMHO the right direction is not (as most people tend to think) following every Microsoft move and try to make Mono 100% compliant. Mono has to be a platform on its own. There are unique features to Linux or Solaris, MacOS, HP-UX or S-390 systems where Mono runs. Features that could be used from Mono apps making it the best platform to develop code on our beloved Unix boxes. And, obviously, this support won't come from the implementation of the latest .NET x.x feature.

During the first releases Mono tried to catch up with .NET, and it was worth the effort. But now Mono is mature enough to choose which features are worth implementing in the future, and which ones forget to focus on new unique ones.

And there are already nice examples of unique features, some of them I'm really amazed of. Just to mention a few:

  • The new (you've to download the latest 2.2 code and build it to try it) csharp interactive shell, which opens a number of new possibilities ranging from interactive process diagnostics to implementing server side shells based on Mono code.
  • Assembly runtime code injection. Ok, focus only on the nasty things you can do with it and you're lost, but try to be positive and creative: better plugins, better runtime extensions, process diagnostic for complex systems, and so on.
  • The C# evaluator which converts the whole compiler into a powerful expression runner with applications for application scripting and so on
  • MonoFUSE (after remoting and DCOM, filesystems are my second favorite thing :-P) which allows you to create filesystems directly on Mono. Ok, this one is not an unique feature on its own since you can also do it in a number of other languages but, as I pointed out before... it's easier and funnier with Mono!

Wrapping up

This is my first blog post here, and it was a real pleasure for me to be able to talk a little bit about my favorite OSS project ever: Mono. I know there's still a lot to do, a lot to improve, new steps and new projects to finish, but they're on their way. My core is SCM, version control, agile methods and so on, and that's what I'll be normally covering on this column, but I'll try to save some time to make some Mono based experiments.

I like Mono for server side apps but I can only be excited to think what would happen if, at some point in the future, Linux based GUI apps and their underlying frameworks would be Mono-written. :-)

Illusion



Comments (0)Add Comment

Write comment
You must be logged in to a comment. Please register if you do not have an account yet.

busy

Get your FREE Subscription to Dr. Dobb’s Digest today!

Dobbs Code Talk Quick Poll

This time next year, your most important operating system (host and/or target) will be:

Look Who's Code Talking


Mark Sellers
City: Colorado Springs

Charlie Shively
City: Holliston

Craig Wilder
City: Mpls.

Allan Metts
City: Duluth

Michael Hohmeyer
City: Berkeley

David Barker
City: Tukwila

Dobbs Code Talk Tags

.NET abstraction Ada Adobe Agile Ajax algorithm Algorithmic complexity ALM Analogical reasoning Android Anecdotes Apple Application Development AppStore Architecture and Design ARM Artificial Intelligence Artificial Life Assembler Programming Audio files AVX AWK Banking Bazaar Best Practices Blender Books Brain computer interfacing Build C C Programming C Sharp Cartoon Category theory Cellular automata Clojure Cloud Computing Cobol Cocoa Coder Of The Month Cognition as compression Collaboration Common Process/Frameworks Compilers Computational humour Computational narrative Computational politics Computer Science Computers in art computing pioneers concurrency Conferences Consciousness research Contest Contest140 contests CPlusPlus crime CSharp D Programming Data Centers Databases Debugging Delphi Deployment design Design Patterns Digital Signal Processing Distributed Django Documentation DSL dynamic language Eclipse EDA education Emacs Embedded Systems Encryption engineering Erlang Etymology Excel exception handling Facebook Financial computing Five Questions Flash Flash Lite Flex Forth Fortran Fraud FreeBSD Fun Functional Programming gadgets Games Gender Git gnuplot Go Google Graphics GUI hardware Heron High School High-Performance Computing History Holographic reduced representations HTML5 Humanity Humour Hungarian Notation Identity Inkscape Innovation Intel Interview iPhone J2EE Java JavaFX JavaOne JavaScript language engineering Legal lex LINQ Linux Lisp Literate Programming Logic Programming m4 Mainframes Make Mathematica Mercurial Mesh messaging Metaprogramming Microsoft MID Miscellaneous Musings ML Mobile Software Mobility modeling modular programming multicore Music MVC myblog Natural Language Processing Networking Neural networks newspeak Nokia numerical computing Object Rexx ObjectiveC Office Office 2007 Online spreadsheets OOP Open Source Openaccess publishing OpenBSD OpenSolaris Operating Systems Optimization Oracle Pair Programming Parallelism Concurrency Parsing Pascal Patents Patterns Performance Perl PHP Podcast Pop11 Poplog Privacy Processing Productivity Programming Language Implementation Programming Language One Programming language semantics Programming Languages Programming Style Project Management Prolog Psychology Public understanding of science puzzle Python QA Quantum Computing Quotes Rails Realtime recls Requirements Research practice REST Review RIA rich internet applications Robotics Ruby SaaS Software as a service Scala Schadenfreude Science fiction Screencast Scripting SD Best Practices Search Security Semantic Web Silverlight Snobol SOA social Social Networks Society for the Study of Artificial Intelligence a Software Development Methodology and Management Songs and poems Spending Priorities Spreadsheets SQL Startups Statistics Storage String pattern matching Survey Teaching Testing The Business of Programming The Dobbs Challenge The Future Theory Topology Transhumanism Travel on the Job Twitter Types Unix Upgrade Usability Use Cases USENET User Experience User Interface Design Version Control video virtual machines Virtualization Visual Studio Visual Studio Sponsored Post WCF Web Development Windows Windows 7 Windows Live Wireless WOA WPF X Window System yacc

Subscribe to Dr. Dobbs Newsletter

Email:
Dr. Dobb's Update
Delivered twice a week, Dr. Dobb's Update provides unbiased and objective news, commentary and technical features spanning the entire software development marketplace.

Latest Comments

Jonathan's Last Day at Sun
For the 8 years I worked there, it was fantastic. I worked there under McNealy and I have undying admiration for the guy. I only knew Jonathan periphe...
Implementing Thread Local Storage on OS ...
Back in the day, I did a fair amount of work with PThreads. Wonderful design. Some quirks, but basically really, really nice. Although I wrote a lot ...
More Technonecrophilia with Snobol One-L...
Yeah, It's probably identical except for the (embedded) copy number, I would think. Once it became freely distributable, the copy I've been distribut...
More Technonecrophilia with Snobol One-L...
There's a spitbol-3.7-win.exe at http://code.google.com/p/spitbol/downloads/list . I found it via Dave Shield's blog page http://daveshields.wordpress...
Jonathan's Last Day at Sun
Sadness.

The Latest From Our Member Blogs

How To Select Trainees
Written by Joel Wiesen   
01/27/10
Hiring the right trainee can be harder than hiring a trained programmer.  One approach is described at my website: http://www.aprtestingservices.com/business/lpat/
 
Technical Job Interviews
Written by Keith Kerlan   
01/20/10
What is the best way to interview for software developer positions?  I've been on both sides of the job interviewing table, but have been on the interviewee side of some not too  great inter
 
Timers/timeouts in multi-threaded event-loops
Written by Christof Meerwald   
01/03/10
The traditional way to integrate timeout handling (or timers) in (single-threaded) event loops was to just pass the appropriate timeout value to the select/poll/epoll syscall. While this works fine
 
C vs C++
Written by Issam Lahlali   
12/04/09
I think that the debate "C vs C++" will end when the two langages died, and each one have its advantages and inconvenients, the choice of one instead of another depend on the application c
 
Great Jobs at CISCO
Written by Brent Rogers   
11/30/09
Hello! I am a recruiter at CISCO. We have a number of great jobopportunities at CISCO right now. Please take a look at the job links listedbelow and please send me an updated resume if you are interes
 
OK Labs, ST-Ericsson, and the Mobile/Wireless Ecosystem
Written by Steve Subar   
11/17/09
Two weeks ago, OK Labs and ST-Ericsson announced the selection of OK Labs as ST-Ericsson's mobile virtualization partner. To earn this coveted position, OK Labs prevailed in a rigorous evaluation
 
C++ Ninjas Needed in Santa Clara, California
Written by Brent Rogers   
09/30/09
Hello! I am a recruiter at CISCO. Our PostPath teamin Santa Clara is building a new Email SaaS business at CISCO. We are looking forsenior developers with Zimbra expertise to help us accomplish this t
 
Fighting Fragmentation with Mobile Virtualization
Written by Steve Subar   
09/21/09
Last week Motorola and T-Mobile announced the launch of a new and innovative Android-based smartphone, the Cliq. This attractive, feature-rich slider handset happens to build on a chipset and firmware
 
Insights into Router Design: Unit Testing of Networking Protocols
Written by Rajesh Kumar Venkateswaran   
09/07/09
  Unit testing is a software validation methodology through which a programmer tests individual modules or units of source code. If the programmer has been responsible for developing a networ
 
Insights into Router Design: Implementation of Networking Protocols
Written by Rajesh Kumar Venkateswaran   
09/06/09
  Modern data networking consists of a large number of networking protocols, each of which has its own domain of applicability. Some run on end stations (also called hosts), some on enterp
 
Insights and Innovations in Networking
Written by Rajesh Kumar Venkateswaran   
09/05/09
Networking devices such as routers and switches have evolved quite a bit over the past years, both in the service provider network and in the enterprise. It is a challenge to build these devices, bo
 
reddit threads community
Written by Christof Meerwald   
08/30/09
I have just started a threads community over at reddit to cover topics such as multithreading, concurrency and parallel programming. Feel free to join if you are interested. -- cmeerw.org 
 

The Latest From Dr. Dobbs

DDJ